Jesse Eisenberg in "Manodrome" (2023)
"Manodrome," written and directed by John Trengove, is a harrowing and thought-provoking exploration of masculine rage, toxic ideologies, and the allure of extremism in the face of personal crisis. At the heart of the film is Ralphie, a deeply troubled man played with unsettling conviction by Jesse Eisenberg. While the film has its flaws, it remains a compelling watch due to its important themes, strong performances, and artistic ambition.
Jesse Eisenberg's Empathetic Portrayal
Eisenberg's casting as Ralphie is a masterstroke. His typically cerebral, nervy persona is at odds with Ralphie's attempts to embody a more traditional, stoic masculinity, underlining the character's fundamental discomfort in his own skin. Through Eisenberg's performance, we see a man grappling with a host of internal conflicts: abandonment trauma, body image issues, repressed sexuality, and simmering anger.
It's clear that Trengove wants us to pity Ralphie, and Eisenberg does his best to build empathy for this lost soul. We see glimmers of humanity in Ralphie's interactions with his newborn son and in the concern shown by his friend who initially invited him to the masculinity group. These moments suggest a potential for redemption, a hope that Ralphie might find his way back from the brink.
The Strengths of "Manodrome"
Important Topic: "Manodrome" tackles the timely and crucial subject of alienated young men falling prey to the myth of alpha male dominance. It's a topic that demands exploration and understanding in our current cultural climate.
Amazing Acting and Production Value: Despite being an independent film, "Manodrome" boasts impressive production values and a talented cast. Jesse Eisenberg delivers a committed, nuanced performance as Ralphie, bringing depth to a challenging role.
Provocative Ambiguity: The film keeps the audience guessing about the main character's inner world. While some of this ambiguity may stem from the filmmakers' limitations, much of it feels intentional and in line with the film's art house sensibilities.
Perfect Length: At 95 minutes, "Manodrome" strikes a good balance between character complexity and running time. In an era of bloated runtimes, especially among established filmmakers, this film doesn't overstay its welcome. As a filmmaker who has watched countless movies over the years, I'm growing weary of films that are unnecessarily long, often requiring me to watch them in multiple sittings due to their excessive length.
The Inevitability of Descent
However, these glimpses of hope are fleeting, overwhelmed by the relentless downward spiral of Ralphie's journey. As he becomes more enmeshed in the toxic ideology of Adrien Brody's Dan and his cult-like group, Ralphie's behavior grows increasingly volatile and self-destructive. He lashes out at his pregnant girlfriend, neglects his responsibilities, and disappears into the twisted world of the "Manodrome."
This is where the film's fatal flaw emerges. Despite Eisenberg's best efforts, Ralphie's descent feels inevitable, predetermined by the script's uncompromising bleakness. There are no real turning points, no moments where Ralphie's trajectory might shift. The glimpses of hope - his care for his son, his friend's concern - are ultimately too brief and inconsequential to counterbalance the overwhelming darkness. They never make a real impact on the character's internal process.
A Flawed but Valuable Film
Despite its imperfections, I believe "Manodrome" is a film worth watching and discussing. As a filmmaker myself, I've seen countless movies over the years, and I've grown weary of formulaic, "by-the-numbers" productions. I'm drawn to films that take risks and challenge the audience, even if they don't fully succeed.
Areas for Improvement
Injecting Hope: One of the film's main weaknesses is the unrelenting bleakness of Ralphie's arc. While the filmmakers may have intended this, injecting some genuine hope or the possibility of redemption could have made Ralphie's struggle more engaging and impactful. We don't truly believe that Ralphie can stop his descent into the abyss of violence and despair. Even if the filmmakers wanted the main character to end badly and for the film to be a tragedy, it would have been much more powerful if the positive influences in his life were really meaningful and his internal struggle was more palpable. Giving Ralphie a genuine chance at redemption, even if he ultimately fails, would have added depth and nuance to his character's journey.
Underdeveloped Subplots: The script introduces several potentially interesting subplots, such as Ralphie's friend's concern about the cult and their distancing conversations while carrying firewood. This theme was intriguing but never fully developed, missing the opportunity to instill real doubt in Ralphie about the damage the cult could do to his life. Similarly, Ralphie's sexual fascination with his colleague at the gym is another promising thread that never quite reaches its potential in terms of its significance to the main character. These subplots could have been powerful tools to showcase Ralphie's internal conflict and the possibility of a different path, but they remain underutilized, ultimately feeling like missed opportunities to add complexity to Ralphie's arc.
Inconsistent Character Logic: Some of the film's plot points, such as Ralphie's girlfriend leaving him and their newborn child, feel insufficiently set up. The girlfriend's decision, while intended to raise the stakes, comes across as artificial because her character was never properly established as emotionally unstable or capable of abandoning her child. In crafting a compelling narrative, it's crucial to lay the groundwork for major character decisions and plot developments. Introducing Ralphie's girlfriend as a potentially unstable person from the outset would have made her ultimate decision more believable and impactful. Plot points designed to raise the stakes are essential in driving the story forward, but they need to be earned through careful character development and foreshadowing. Failing to do so can undermine the authenticity of the narrative and break the audience's immersion in the story.
As a result, the film becomes a one-note portrait of a man's destruction. While this may be Trengove's intent, to unflinchingly depict the allure and consequences of toxic masculinity, the lack of any real hope or redemption robs the narrative of dramatic tension. We are left to watch passively as Ralphie spirals ever downward, with no sense that another outcome is possible.
Echoes of "Taxi Driver" and "Fight Club"
The comparisons to "Taxi Driver" and "Fight Club" are inevitable, given the shared themes of male alienation and the seductive power of violent ideologies. Like Travis Bickle and The Narrator, Ralphie is a man who feels disconnected from the world around him, seeking belonging and purpose in all the wrong places.
However, where those films used voiceover narration to fully immerse us in their protagonists' twisted worldviews, "Manodrome" keeps us at a slight remove. We are privy to Ralphie's experience, but not his inner thoughts, which can leave the character feeling somewhat opaque. This choice robs the film of some of the unsettling complicity that makes "Taxi Driver" and "Fight Club" so powerful, as we are never forced to confront our own potential alignment with Ralphie's perspective.
Hidden Meaning
This analysis would be incomplete if I didn't try my best to pinpoint what this film is about. The hidden meaning of a film is the underlying message or theme that the filmmaker aims to convey through the story, characters, and symbolism, without explicitly stating it in the dialogue or narration. My guess is that in "Manodrome," the filmmakers went with:
"Unchecked toxic masculinity and the allure of extremist ideologies can lead vulnerable and lost men down a path of destruction, isolation, and violence as they seek a sense of belonging and purpose."
This message is never directly expressed in the film but is instead reinforced through the symbolic elements, character arcs, and the overall trajectory of the narrative.
Now let's try to find a shorter version of this thought that would be useful in your work on a film set. By distilling the film's hidden meaning into this powerful, concise statement, a director can maintain a laser-like focus on the story's central theme throughout the production process. It serves as a constant reminder of the film's purpose and can help guide decisions regarding performance, cinematography, editing, and other aspects of the filmmaking process. As a director, having such a clear and impactful phrase in mind can be invaluable when making quick decisions on set and providing guidance to the cast and crew. This short version acts as a personal beacon, ensuring that every creative choice aligns with the film's core message.
Let's go with:
"Masculinity unchecked breeds destruction."
This short version of the hidden meaning is like a punch in the face – it grabs attention, provokes thought, and leaves a lasting impact, much like the film itself aims to do. It serves as a powerful and concise encapsulation of the film's central theme.
The word "unchecked" suggests a lack of restraint or control, while "breeds" implies a sense of growth or propagation. This combination of words highlights the insidious nature of toxic masculinity and how, if left unchallenged, it can fester and give rise to destructive behaviors and outcomes.
The inclusion of the word "destruction" adds a layer of violence and severity to the phrase, emphasizing the dire consequences that can result from unchecked toxic masculinity. It's a jolting reminder of the potential harm that can be inflicted on both the individual and those around them when aggressive, domineering, and emotionally stunted forms of masculinity are allowed to run rampant.
It's not perfect but still watch it
In the end, "Manodrome" is a flawed but fascinating exploration of male desperation and the dark allure of extremism. It's a film that challenges and disturbs, and in doing so, it fulfills one of the key roles of art-house cinema. For those willing to engage with its difficult themes and imperfect execution, "Manodrome" offers a thought-provoking and memorable viewing experience.
Commenti